Buy Read Learn Yankee Fans Red Sox Fans Inside Pitch Fan On The Street Links Contact
Moments Stories Madisonography 1918 Media Gallery  
 
Back

From The Archives - A Look Back At An Unforgivable Moment In Time:
Sox opening day 2005


Now that the Yankees have had a chance to revisit and demostrate how to properly win, celebrate and act like World Champions we can finally put to rest one of the most insultng episodes in rivalry history: Opening Day 2005, and for that matter the entire 2004 Red Sox experience.

Did the Red Sox, their fans, and for that matter Boston and all of New England, understand that wining the 2004 World Championship limited them to actually being the 2004 World Champions?

Based on the aftermath it seemed that every Sox team that choked or collapsed prior to 2004 instantly became the new co-World Champions. Did Major League Baseball change the rules so that every team and player in the history of the franchise gets to jump up and down in celebratory glee?


Before you feel compelled to point out that "old Yankees" grandstand in the clubhouse every time the Yanks secure a division title or pennant, put a Sox in it! All those old Yankees come fully adorned with their own rings; bought and paid for with their own toil and triumph.

Sox fans always deride the Yankees and their fans for living in the past and droning on about 27 28 World Championships, but, have you ever heard a Yankee of the 1996 to 2000 or 2009 vintage dedicate a championship to his pinstriped ancestors? Acknowledge? Yes. Include? No.

The same holds true with the fan base which elects to view winning as a progression and the next link in a glorious tradition. When the Yankees beat the Phillies in 2009, it was no more a victory for the 2001 Yankees than the Phille's loss was a crushing reversal for their ancestral brethren, the 1980 Phillies.

Does the Sox winning the 2004 World Series mean that their ancestors of '86, '75 and '67 won as well? I guess the Mets, Reds and Cardinals will be hearing from Bud Selig soon to inform them of the sudden retroactive victories of the Red Sox. The truth is simply that 2004 is only relative to 2004. We are weary of hearing about how the '04 Sox have vindicated, absolved, and otherwise redeemed all previous Boston underachievers.

Win or lose, Yankee teams stand alone unless linked via sequential or clustered Championships ('77 & '78, '96 to 2000) or sustained post season appearances ('95 to 2007). In non championship years, Yankees and fans possess the admirable trait of honoring the past while playing in the present and anticipating the future.

What happened at Fenway in 2005 was not an opening day ceremony; it was a revival meeting. The only thing they did not do was dunk old Red Sox in the Charles. Yankee fans are not about redemption, we leave that for the Sox. We're about class, style and tradition. That Opening day at Fenway was not about celebrating and embracing. It was an exorcism; the Sox and their fans did not reclaim their past, they banished it! By forever linking past failures to current success, they have diminished the noble and valiant accomplishments of current and past players.

High Mass at Fenway could only be complete with the presence of the Yankees. And what did they do while being forced to watch this spectacle? They stood and applauded. If the situation was the other way around, do you really think the Red Sox would have stood and applauded in their dugout at Yankee Stadium?

All that welcoming of the past and the making right of old wrongs is more about fear of the past returning than it is about ushering in a new era (error?). The Yankees will always be in their heads and our presence was required to complete the exorcism; after all, how can you banish "evil" if it does not even show up?

Truth be told, the Yankees lost to the Red Sox that year, but we held onto our class. George Steinbrenner ordered the Yankees to show up and Francona ordered the Sox to shut up; who had more class and style?

Now that Championship number 28 showed up in the Bronx it brought with it the ultimate satisfaction of finishing in first place and clinching the AL East against the Sox at home in The Bronx. Opening Day 2010 contained all the proper acknowledgement of 2009 and claimed its place in the naturalt progresion in the march to Championship number 29. What did not happen was an absolution, inclusion and forgiveness of all things 2001 to 2008. The way it should be.

The trophy is back where it belongs and though we were denied the chance during the playoffs, as lest we got to beat the Sox during the regular season. And will again and again. Sox Opening Day 2005 is now avenged, the only regret is that the Sox were not on hand Opening Day 2010 ay Yankee Stadium to have the point reinforced that order in the baseball universe has been restored and shall remain there for the foreseeable future.

Buy Read Learn Yankee Fans Red Sox Fans Inside Pitch Fan On The Street Links Contact
Fandamonium Copyright 2004© Fandamonium.net Copyright 2009© Legal